Saturday, March 5, 2016

Finite Element Analysis: A Technical Revolution


Technology allows change in every field. In many cases, these innovations force us to completely abandon everything we know and start from scratch. Such a revolution is currently underway in one of the oldest sciences there is: the science of keeping buildings upright.

The primary ignition of this revolution is increased use of the computer. Computer Aided Design software was initially introduced in the 1980s. As computers became more powerful, the companies making the software updated to match. Quite recently, though, new innovations in physics and mathematics have forced structural analysis models to restart from the ground up.

Before I explain the new technology, let me draw your attention back to the departure concourse of London’s historic Kings Cross Station, pictured in the back banner. The departure course was designed by Arup and was opened in 2012. The original Kings Cross Station is Grade I-listed, which is Great Britain’s most sensitive historic preservation rating. Because of the listing, the structure for the departure concourse had to be completely independent of the original building.

Arup’s design idea was a “reverse waterfall,” a funnel of gleaming white metal tubes. The point is, this diagrid shell could not have been designed in 2010. The difference: a complete revolution in the mathematics and physics used to design structures.

Traditional structural analysis methods use approximations and simplifications to reduce the mathematics to a level that can be solved with pencil and paper. These simplifications and approximations are accurate enough to let us design great monuments such as the Empire State Building without fearing it’s collapse. But they are inadequate in attempting to describe the forces along more complex or irregular structures. The Empire State Building is, basically, a bunch of stacked boxes. In contrast, there are very few horizontal or vertical beams in Arup’s diagrid shell.

In order to break these boundaries, engineers had to abandon the traditional equations and return to fundamental physics. New methods of problem solving were developed, this time designed based on computer processing. The resulting package is called finite element analysis.

The beauty of fundamental analysis is it can be applied outside of structures to analyze the flow of fluids or paths of lighting. It works by taking a large system, reducing it to smaller, manageable pieces, and calculating how those pieces interact. The software operator can decide whether to use fewer, larger pieces for quick calculations or have more, smaller pieces for more exact results.

Primarily because finite element analysis is not restricted to tried-and-true geometries, it allows architects to explore new forms and building shapes. This gives the architect more flexibility in creating efficient and interesting rooms. It also encourages a change in architectural style, opening the doors to a new era of architecture.